advertise
Vanislander / Landmarks / Caves / Fishy Hole Cave

Fishy Hole Cave on Vancouver Island

Vancouver Island, often dubbed the "Island of Caves," boasts over 1,000 known caves, attracting adventurers and nature enthusiasts worldwide. Among these, Fishy Hole Cave emerges as a lesser-known yet fascinating destination, offering a raw and thrilling experience for seasoned cavers. Located near the Memekay River in the Comox Valley, this cave blends natural beauty with the challenge of exploration. In this article, we’ll dive into the evidence confirming Fishy Hole Cave’s existence, its unique features, and what it takes to explore this hidden gem—all based on available information, excluding any reliance on vanislander.com.

Location and Context 

 Nestled in the Comox Valley near the Memekay River, Fishy Hole Cave lies within a region renowned for its karst landscapes—limestone formations sculpted over millennia into caves, sinkholes, and underground rivers. Its name may hint at its proximity to the river or the watery echoes from its depths. Local lore suggests hikers stumbled upon it after feeling a sudden rush of cool air in the forest, a classic sign of a concealed cave entrance. This discovery underscores its status as a hidden treasure, distinct from more tourist-friendly caves like Little Huson Caves or Horne Lake Caves.

More

Less

What to Expect 

Fishy Hole Cave is a formidable natural wonder. At 70 meters deep and 165 meters long, it’s a significant cave, featuring an underground river at its base—a highlight that amplifies both its beauty and its challenges. Unlike polished tourist destinations, it lacks formal trails or guided tours, preserving its rugged, unspoiled character. Expect a demanding interior with slippery surfaces, narrow passages, and the constant sound of water, creating an immersive yet intense caving experience. Its listing as the 58th deepest cave in a registry underscores its stature among Vancouver Island’s subterranean marvels.

More

Less

Safety and Access

Exploring Fishy Hole Cave is not a casual outing—it requires preparation and expertise. Here’s what you need to know:
Team Up with Experts: Its depth, river, and remote setting make it a technical challenge best tackled with experienced cavers who know the ropes (literally and figuratively).
Plan Ahead: Tell someone your itinerary and expected return time, as cell service is unreliable in such remote areas. Gear Up: Bring helmets, headlamps, ropes, waterproof clothing, sturdy boots, and a first aid kit. The cave’s wet, rocky environment demands top-notch equipment.
Tread Lightly: Caves are fragile ecosystems—avoid disturbing formations or wildlife and leave no trace. Getting there is an adventure in itself. The Comox Valley’s remote terrain likely requires navigating deactivated logging roads or overgrown trails. 

More

Less

Conservation and Significance

 Vancouver Island’s caves, including Fishy Hole Cave, are more than just playgrounds for adventurers—they’re vital ecological havens. These dark, damp spaces often host rare species and delicate formations, making conservation a priority. While Fishy Hole Cave lacks formal protection or extensive surveys, its recognition in local caving circles highlights its role in the island’s karst heritage. Responsible exploration is key to preserving this natural wonder for future generations.

More

Less

Why Visit Fishy Hole Cave? 

Fishy Hole Cave beckons those who thrive on adventure and discovery. Its remote location, technical demands, and the thrill of an underground river set it apart from more accessible caves. The lack of commercialization and its informal, almost secretive status lend it an air of exclusivity. For cavers willing to tackle the logistics and physical challenges, it offers a rare chance to connect with Vancouver Island’s untamed wilderness and geological splendor.

More

Less

Vancouver Island Activities

Madrona Point Diving

Madrona Point Diving

Being a famous diving zone. Madrona Point provides divers from all skill levels with undeniable diving opportunities within a short distance from Nanaimo. It includes three walls: Small, Mid, and Maze walls, of which an amazing marine life is observable near the Small wall and deep-diving near the Maze wall.

Camping in Newcastle Island Marine Provincial Park Campground

Camping in Newcastle Island Marine Provincial Park Campground

Nothing can feed your spirit like a clean, relaxing vacation. To do so, you have fantastic chances to camp in Newcastle Island Marine Provincial Park Campground and let your lungs to be flourished by the fresh air you let in. These oceanside campgrounds have a lot to offer: ample amenities, various wildlife and astonishing scenery. Camping at this campsite is something that happens once in a lifetime.

Willows Beach Kiteboarding

Willows Beach Kiteboarding

You will feel phenomenal when you reach this beautiful beach, particularly when you step into the water. Willows Beach is mainly known for its swimming opportunity, but you are given a chance to surf the surface of the water. It is highly appropriate for young children, and ample amenities are provided for your convenience.

Cabin Point Whale Watching

Cabin Point Whale Watching

You would better plan a visit to Cabin Point Coastline between April-September. It is the best time for those preparing for Sooke Whale Watching in one of the famous coastlines for it in the Salish sea. You are given adequate opportunity to gaze upon these marvellous sea creatures.

Camping in the China Beach Campground

Camping in the China Beach Campground

Camping in the China Beach Campground would revise your assumption f camping to its best version. A quiet semi-private campground where your relaxing getaway vacation is guaranteed. You are allowed to even camp on the beautiful sand beach and feel the warmth of the sand while walking on it. Remarkable sea life might be observable from the beach.

Elliot's Beach Park Diving

Elliot's Beach Park Diving

Make your time on Vancouver Island count and go diving in Elliot's Beach Park. It is a pristine diving location for professional diving, but it has opportunities to discover underwater for ordinary folks.

Port Hardy Whale Watching

Port Hardy Whale Watching

Looking for a way through which you can make your adventure on Vancouver Island unforgettable? Do not forget to stop by Port hardy while you are in the northern parts of the island. There you will be able to sight magnificent killer whales, near which you should apply ample caution. However, observing them is better an oops than a what if.

Camping in Tribune Bay Campground-Hornby Island

Camping in Tribune Bay Campground-Hornby Island

In Tribune Bay Campground-Hornby Island, you would have the chance to spend your time on grass or the area covers by green trees. There might be one of the best places to spend time with your family and an excellent opportunity to observe different flora and fauna. The camp is next to a co-op if one needs anything necessary, which is great for campers.

Jordan River Kayaking

Jordan River Kayaking

For those who seek sea paddling, the Jordan River might be a potential destination to satisfy their desires for kayaking. Another merit of visiting Jordan River is that it is surrounded by some recreational sites which guarantee your stay to be adventurous. Camping areas around the Jordan River facilitate a long kayaking experience.

Campbell River Whale Watching

Campbell River Whale Watching

Get on the board of a Zodiac-style vessel while sailing towards the heart of the water to the sea, watch the giant mammals in the world among other marine creatures. While experiencing Campbell River Whale Watching, you will encounter a rare natural beauty home to diverse wildlife. Campbell River, the salmon capital of the world, is the origin of several tours launching into the Strait of Georgia.

Vancouver Island Activities

Camping in Fillongley Provincial Park Campground

Camping in Fillongley Provincial Park Campground

If you got a few days free and you plan to spend it on Vancouver Island, pay a visit to Fillongely Provincial Park to experience every possible way of camping. Nestled amongst lush green deciduous trees, visitors would enjoy excellent hiking trails with picturesque sights. This quiet, clean, and grassy park provides you with exciting activities and a gorgeous ocean and forest view.

Nanaimo Diving

Nanaimo Diving

Ranked as the best cold-water diving destination in BC, Nanaimo waters are saturated with new diving experiences. BC Ferries, dive shops, accessible shores, and the chance to observe cute beaches have made Nanaimo an ideal destination for visitors. Diving enthusiasts find themselves in the heavens when they come to Nanaimo, for it is home to spotless diving spots.

Mount Washington Snowboarding

Mount Washington Snowboarding

As the second busiest winter recreational destination in BC, Mt. Washington Ski Resort in Comox Valley offers a wide range of snowboarding facilities. Mountain climbing enthusiasts who choose Mount Washington for snowboarding have the chance to look across the Strait of Georgia and other spectacular views, such as the Strathcona Provincial Park region.

Kwisitis Visitor Centre Storm Watching

Kwisitis Visitor Centre Storm Watching

Have you ever experienced storm watching on a perched deck overlooking an eye-catching view of the Pacific Ocean? If not, Kwisitis Visitor Centre is awaiting you. As a beautiful exhibition for the natural and cultural patrimony of Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, this excellent Centre offers unforgettable storm watching right on the Pacific shores, which guarantees your fun and adventure.

Hiking on the Mount Menzies Access Road

Hiking on the Mount Menzies Access Road

Hiking on the Mount Menzies Access Road through a logging road and having a forest walk is a challenge you can take near the Campbell River. The trail and the view from the lookout are incredible in colours. Get away from the humans by going on a beautiful trail which is nice and quiet!

Elk / Beaver Lake Regional Park Windsurfing

Elk / Beaver Lake Regional Park Windsurfing

What you see in Elk / Beaver Lake Regional Park is never what you had heard about it. A beautiful park featuring two lakes has a lot to offer. Elk / Beaver Lake Regional Park is a hot spot for answering your cravings for water activities, particularly windsurfing. There are also some popular land activities you can find exciting right on the shore.

Camping in Bedwell Lake Campground

Camping in Bedwell Lake Campground

Known as the base camp to explore the area, Bedwell Lake Campground comprises excellent tent campsites. There you can climb surrounding mountains and hike gorgeous, well-maintained trails. Bedwell Lake Campground would be excellent for backcountry adventures. It has lovely glacial mountain views.

Camping in Quatse River Campground

Camping in Quatse River Campground

Nestled in old-growth forests, Quatse River Campground offers peaceful camping next to the bank of Quatse River. This campground provides you with privacy and peace away from the busy urban life comprising a green and treed atmosphere. Also, admirers of nature can enjoy a diversity of flora and fauna while drowning in other adventures.

Cox Bay Kiteboarding

Cox Bay Kiteboarding

Great opportunities for kiteboarding are awaiting you in the realm of Cox Bay, no matter if you are an expert or a beginner. But beforehand, check the reports and wave directions. Besides, the magnificent beach of Cox bay offers an abundance of activities you may enjoy.

West Coast Trail

West Coast Trail

The West Coast Trail is a world-renowned multi-day backpacking trail, stretching 75 kilometers (47 miles) along the rugged southwestern coast of Vancouver Island, British Columbia, Canada. This iconic trail, often referred to as the 75-kilometer West Coast Trail on Vancouver Island, winds through the wild beauty of Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, offering hikers a challenging yet rewarding adventure. Known for its stunning scenery, historical significance, and unique features like wobbly ladders, cable cars, and tidal crossings, the West Coast Trail Vancouver Island BC spans a 48.3-mile point-to-point trail near Anacla 12, close to the Nitinaht village. Managed by Parks Canada, this legendary national park trail blends natural wonders with cultural insights tied to the Balaats’adt region.
Originally established in 1889 as a telegraph line connecting Victoria to Bamfield, the trail evolved into the Life Saving Trail following the tragic 1906 SS Valencia shipwreck, which earned the area the nickname "Graveyard of the Pacific." Today, it attracts adventurers with its dense forests, sandy beaches, and rocky shorelines, making it a top destination for hikers. With camping sites along the route and nearby accommodations like the West Coast Trail lodge in Port Renfrew or Bamfield, the trail caters to both seasoned trekkers and first-timers.

Vancouver Island Activities

Deep Bay Windsurfing

Deep Bay Windsurfing

Discover your windsurfing spirit while you are in the Deep Bay area. Waterfowl in the winter months have made these protected waters a hot spot for windsurfing. Due to Deep Bay's proximity to Baynes Sound, visitors can enjoy several other outdoor adventures. Also, more recreational opportunities are provided in the park and the golf club nearby.

Campbell River Whale Watching

Campbell River Whale Watching

Get on the board of a Zodiac-style vessel while sailing towards the heart of the water to the sea, watch the giant mammals in the world among other marine creatures. While experiencing Campbell River Whale Watching, you will encounter a rare natural beauty home to diverse wildlife. Campbell River, the salmon capital of the world, is the origin of several tours launching into the Strait of Georgia.

Wreck of the SS Themis Diving

Wreck of the SS Themis Diving

No one can imagine a sank ship's wrecks can make an ideal place to dive deep in the water. Wreck of the SS Themis Diving is a habitat for a small diversity of marine creatures, and it is a beautiful background view for your pictures.

Zeballos Kayaking and Canoeing

Zeballos Kayaking and Canoeing

Although the city is known for its gold mining, Zeballos is a fantastic destination for paddling activities. Great hiking trail within the rainforest in which various wildlife is observable. Kayakers and canoeing followers may have the chance to explore a place with several underground caves and spelunking places. Not to mention that other outdoor activities can add to your joy in Zeballos.

Stories Beach Surfing

Stories Beach Surfing

As a reward for your hard work, travel to Vancouver Island to fulfil your cravings for adventure and fun. Adjacent to Campbell River, Stories Beach is a vibrant spot attracting many visitors worldwide. The great waves heating the beach allow you to experience surfing for real. While you are in the area, keep in mind to fish; so, do not forget to bring your fishing rods.

Mount Washington Snowboarding

Mount Washington Snowboarding

As the second busiest winter recreational destination in BC, Mt. Washington Ski Resort in Comox Valley offers a wide range of snowboarding facilities. Mountain climbing enthusiasts who choose Mount Washington for snowboarding have the chance to look across the Strait of Georgia and other spectacular views, such as the Strathcona Provincial Park region.

Octopus Point Diving

Octopus Point Diving

Adventure lovers who know nothing about diving but look forward to experience it may find the Octopus Point Diving site the best place to go. In these shallow waters, several marine life is observable, and the safety of your diving is guaranteed to a considerable measure.

The Hike to Trent Falls

The Hike to Trent Falls

A relatively short and easy trail in the Comox Valley area is the hike to Trent Falls. Stay on track because its wild nature has much to offer. Hiking along the Trent River with its perfect swimming and fishing opportunities and watching the waterfall with a deep pool under and the wildlife around it brings you joy, especially if you are with the family.

Cadboro Bay Windsurfing

Cadboro Bay Windsurfing

If you have never been to Cadboro Bay, you must know that this marvellous place offering suitable conditions and facilities is an ideal spot for those in love with windsurfing. The Bay's proximity to Cadboro-Gyro Park is the reason why adventure never dies in that region. While you are enjoying one, many others are awaiting you in the field to be experienced.

Tofino Whale Watching

Tofino Whale Watching

Make your adventure worthwhile on Vancouver Island by visiting Tofino and not missing its whale-watching opportunities for the world. You may have the chance to gaze upon Orcas, the most widespread marine mammal on the earth. Clayoquot Sound, located near the Tofino, is a sandy shoreline with rich rainforest.

Fishy Hole Cave, a renowned Vancouver Island karst cave, is primarily composed of ancient limestone deposits formed in shallow marine environments. Over millions of years, chemical weathering, freeze-thaw cycles, and water erosion have sculpted its remarkable speleothem formations such as stalactites and stalagmites. These processes, documented by BC geological studies and modern speleological research, make Fishy Hole Cave a prime example of Canadian karst landscapes.
Profile Picture

Anita Akhoundi

2025 April 6

Your Adventure Starts with Vancouver Island Tours

4 Hour Scenic Tour and Salmon Fishing | VI-FT-014

Private coastal sightseeing and salmon fishing charter departing from Nanaimo, perfect for families and anglers of all levels.
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $660
4 Hours
4 Hour Scenic Tour and Salmon Fishing | VI-FT-014

8hr Nanaimo Private Fishing Tour | VI-FT-013

Full Day Private Fishing Adventure in the Stunning Waters of Nanaimo
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $1,200
8 Hours
8hr Nanaimo Private Fishing Tour | VI-FT-013

6 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter | VI-FT-012

Private 6-Hour Vancouver Island Salmon Fishing Charter in Nanaimo
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $960
6 hours
6 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter | VI-FT-012

4 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter Private Tour | VI-FT-011

Private Guided Salmon Fishing Adventure in Nanaimo
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $660
4 Hours
4 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter Private Tour | VI-FT-011

Comox Spring Coastal Explorer & Fishing Trip | VI-FT-009

Explore the Salish Sea on a relaxed guided coastal adventure combining angling, wildlife watching, and island exploration.
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $800
5 to 6.5 hours
Comox Spring Coastal Explorer & Fishing Trip | VI-FT-009

5-Hour Half-Day Salmon Fishing Trip | VI-FT-008

Experience premier guided salmon fishing trips in the Comox Valley with Island Pursuit Sport Fishing.
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $800
5 Hours (Half Day)
5-Hour Half-Day Salmon Fishing Trip | VI-FT-008

Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 6 Hour Trip | VI-FT-007

Experience premium guided fishing trips in Comox targeting salmon, cod, and crab year-round.
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $975
6 Hours (Ranges from 5 to 6.5 hours)
Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 6 Hour Trip | VI-FT-007

Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 8 Hour Day Trip | VI-FT-006

Premier Vancouver Island Fishing Charter Targeting Salmon, Bottom Fish & Crab Year-Round
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $1,275
8 Hours
Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 8 Hour Day Trip | VI-FT-006

Barkley Sound Halibut Fishing Trip | VI-FT-005

Experience world-class halibut jigging and salmon trolling aboard the Oracle with award-winning captain Orest Iwaszko.
Group
Alberni Valley
Barkley Sound
from $0
Multi-day overnight packages, 8-hour salmon and halibut trips, and 5-hour trips available.
Barkley Sound Halibut Fishing Trip | VI-FT-005

Private Sockeye Fishing Trip | VI-FT-004

Experience a private sockeye salmon fishing charter in Alberni Inlet, Vancouver Island. Luxury hybrid-electric trawler, expert captain, and all-inclusive fishing adventure for groups of 4 to 11 people during peak June–July season.
Group
Alberni Valley
Alberni Inlet
from $1,480
Full-Day Trip
Private Sockeye Fishing Trip | VI-FT-004

Private 2 Day Fishing Trip | VI-FT-002

Comfortable, private group fishing adventure in Barkley Sound for up to 11 guests
Group
Port Alberni
Barkley Sound
from $185
8 hours (private trip with flexible pacing based on conditions)
Private 2 Day Fishing Trip | VI-FT-002

Sea Lions & Eagles Adventure

Experience an Unforgettable Half-Day Adventure in the Heart of Fanny Bay
Group
Nanaimo
from $2,850
1 day
Sea Lions & Eagles Adventure

4-Day Wildlife Watching on Vancouver Island

Pacific Rim & Clayoquot Sound Adventure
Group
Nanaimo
Tofino
from $1,897
4 days and 3 nights
4-Day Wildlife Watching on Vancouver Island

Fly Fishing Tour on Vancouver Island

Fly-Fishing Paradise on the Gold River
Group
Campbell River
Gold River BC
from $1,400
1 day
Fly Fishing Tour on Vancouver Island

Victoria Kayak Fishing Adventure Tour

Explore Inner Harbour & Catch Inshore Fish
Group
Victoria
Victoria
from $1,000
2 days and one night
Victoria Kayak Fishing Adventure Tour

Port Renfrew Bottom Fishing Tour

Guided Fishing Adventure Tour on Port Renfrew Vancouver Island
Group
Victoria
Port Renfrew
from $1,475
3 days and 2 nights
Port Renfrew Bottom Fishing Tour

What Do You Think about