advertise
Vanislander / Landmarks / Caves / Fishy Hole Cave

Fishy Hole Cave on Vancouver Island

Vancouver Island, often dubbed the "Island of Caves," boasts over 1,000 known caves, attracting adventurers and nature enthusiasts worldwide. Among these, Fishy Hole Cave emerges as a lesser-known yet fascinating destination, offering a raw and thrilling experience for seasoned cavers. Located near the Memekay River in the Comox Valley, this cave blends natural beauty with the challenge of exploration. In this article, we’ll dive into the evidence confirming Fishy Hole Cave’s existence, its unique features, and what it takes to explore this hidden gem—all based on available information, excluding any reliance on vanislander.com.

Location and Context 

 Nestled in the Comox Valley near the Memekay River, Fishy Hole Cave lies within a region renowned for its karst landscapes—limestone formations sculpted over millennia into caves, sinkholes, and underground rivers. Its name may hint at its proximity to the river or the watery echoes from its depths. Local lore suggests hikers stumbled upon it after feeling a sudden rush of cool air in the forest, a classic sign of a concealed cave entrance. This discovery underscores its status as a hidden treasure, distinct from more tourist-friendly caves like Little Huson Caves or Horne Lake Caves.

More

Less

What to Expect 

Fishy Hole Cave is a formidable natural wonder. At 70 meters deep and 165 meters long, it’s a significant cave, featuring an underground river at its base—a highlight that amplifies both its beauty and its challenges. Unlike polished tourist destinations, it lacks formal trails or guided tours, preserving its rugged, unspoiled character. Expect a demanding interior with slippery surfaces, narrow passages, and the constant sound of water, creating an immersive yet intense caving experience. Its listing as the 58th deepest cave in a registry underscores its stature among Vancouver Island’s subterranean marvels.

More

Less

Safety and Access

Exploring Fishy Hole Cave is not a casual outing—it requires preparation and expertise. Here’s what you need to know:
Team Up with Experts: Its depth, river, and remote setting make it a technical challenge best tackled with experienced cavers who know the ropes (literally and figuratively).
Plan Ahead: Tell someone your itinerary and expected return time, as cell service is unreliable in such remote areas. Gear Up: Bring helmets, headlamps, ropes, waterproof clothing, sturdy boots, and a first aid kit. The cave’s wet, rocky environment demands top-notch equipment.
Tread Lightly: Caves are fragile ecosystems—avoid disturbing formations or wildlife and leave no trace. Getting there is an adventure in itself. The Comox Valley’s remote terrain likely requires navigating deactivated logging roads or overgrown trails. 

More

Less

Conservation and Significance

 Vancouver Island’s caves, including Fishy Hole Cave, are more than just playgrounds for adventurers—they’re vital ecological havens. These dark, damp spaces often host rare species and delicate formations, making conservation a priority. While Fishy Hole Cave lacks formal protection or extensive surveys, its recognition in local caving circles highlights its role in the island’s karst heritage. Responsible exploration is key to preserving this natural wonder for future generations.

More

Less

Why Visit Fishy Hole Cave? 

Fishy Hole Cave beckons those who thrive on adventure and discovery. Its remote location, technical demands, and the thrill of an underground river set it apart from more accessible caves. The lack of commercialization and its informal, almost secretive status lend it an air of exclusivity. For cavers willing to tackle the logistics and physical challenges, it offers a rare chance to connect with Vancouver Island’s untamed wilderness and geological splendor.

More

Less

Vancouver Island Activities

Norris Rocks Diving

Norris Rocks Diving

Diving in Norris Rocks is two birds with one stone. You have the chance for an exciting deep-diving and also observing the unbelievable underwater wildlife inhabiting the area. After jumping into the water, go deep to gaze upon giant octopuses and deep-water locations.

Camping in the Strathcona Provincial Park Campground

Camping in the Strathcona Provincial Park Campground

As the oldest provincial park on the island, Strathcona Provincial Park Campground will be a memorable wilderness adventure. Every day you spend on this beautiful campground is a different new day, for you can experience any adventure and never get sick of it. As a hot spot for camping, you are given a chance to choose the setting of your campsite.

Camping in Croteau Lake Campsite

Camping in Croteau Lake Campsite

The Croteau Lake Campsite is the first backcountry group site accepting reservations, Located within Strathcona Provincial Park in Forbidden Platea. You will have to hike into this lovely remote campground which features a brand new yurt. Nestled in the sub-alpine of Strathcona, Croteau Lake Campsite is surrounded by jagging glacial mountain peaks, and you will experience a sense of peace and seclusion.

Hiking on the Campbell River Canyon View Trail

Hiking on the Campbell River Canyon View Trail

Just outside Campbell River, step into an exciting hiking trail in the middle of a provincial park. It is where the stunning view of Douglas-fir forests comes with a wide variety of wildlife to watch. Find your way alongside the river in a loop which in some parts would be a challenge. It would be great if you plan to be there in the afternoon with a view of the sun when you cross the river.

Nootka Sound Kayaking and Canoeing

Nootka Sound Kayaking and Canoeing

If paddling is frightening for you, make it normal while you are in Nootka Sound. It s worthy of mentioning that while paddling in the waters of Nootka Sound, you are given the pleasure of observing the birth point of BC, Yuquot. Nootka Sound is known as the paradise of the paddlers, and its island provides an extraordinary situation in which an astonishing adventure is waiting to be embraced.

West Coast Hikes

West Coast Hikes

Embark on an unforgettable adventure along Vancouver Island's West Coast, where some of Canada’s most iconic hiking trails beckon outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers alike. From the rugged splendor of the Juan de Fuca Marine Trail to the legendary West Coast Trail, this region boasts a stunning array of hikes that highlight breathtaking coastal vistas, ancient rainforests, and abundant wildlife. Whether you’re craving a challenging multi-day trek or a scenic day hike, trails like the Hesquiat Peninsula and Cape Scott Provincial Park offer unique landscapes steeped in rich history. With paths winding through lush forests, along pristine beaches, and past dramatic cliffs, Vancouver Island hiking delivers an immersive experience in nature’s raw beauty. Discover why this hiker’s paradise is a top destination for adventurers worldwide in this guide to the best West Coast trails.

Nanaimo Whale Watching

Nanaimo Whale Watching

On Vancouver Island, you can spend every single day arriving in a new city comprising magnificent adventures. While you stay in the second-largest city on the island, you may enjoy several incredible activities, including whale watching. Whale watching in Nanaimo gives you the chance to explore the Salish Sea ecosystem and observe marine life from April-October.

Hiking on the Rosewall Creek Trail

Hiking on the Rosewall Creek Trail

Hiking on the Rosewall Creek Trail is a rewarding experience that you reach a beautiful waterfall at the end after an easy hike that may consist of challenges. Enjoy the beauties of the park while passing the lovely well-marked trail with facilities, along the creek and through lush bits of the rainforest.

Hiking on Mount Manuel Quimper

Hiking on Mount Manuel Quimper

It is time to put your heart into hiking and step into a moderate multi-use trail with some great views along the way and on top. Mount Manuel Quimper has a beautiful summit worth the climb, which gives you excellent vistas of Sooke Harbour and a chance to visit one of the last fire lookouts left on the island.

Mount Washington Skiing

Mount Washington Skiing

As one of the biggest and most visited ski resorts in Comox Valley, The Mount Washington resort is a summer-winter destination primed with several facilities to serve skiing followers. The high rate of snowfall and spectacular views of the ocean, and ample facilities for winter activities multiply the attractiveness of Mount Washington.

Vancouver Island Activities

Hiking on the East Sooke Coast Trail

Hiking on the East Sooke Coast Trail

Hiking on the entire East Sooke Coastal Trail is an experience not to be missed! This beautiful trail is a mix of the fantastic coast and beautiful greenery. Hiking boots are required! The route takes you along bluffs and cliffs by the Pacific Ocean that worth it for the views. This well-marked trail can take full-day hiking in East Sooke Regional Park.

Nanaimo Diving

Nanaimo Diving

Ranked as the best cold-water diving destination in BC, Nanaimo waters are saturated with new diving experiences. BC Ferries, dive shops, accessible shores, and the chance to observe cute beaches have made Nanaimo an ideal destination for visitors. Diving enthusiasts find themselves in the heavens when they come to Nanaimo, for it is home to spotless diving spots.

The Jib Diving

The Jib Diving

If you happen to wander around Nanoose Bay, The Jib Diving site is one of the most attractive diving destinations in the region, with a clean environment and easy access. Moreover, except for the beautiful view of the site, you can enjoy watching a diversity of marine life.

Long Beach Storm Watching

Long Beach Storm Watching

As one of the main recreational spots in the Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, Long Beach features strong waves pounding the beach. This quality has made this beautiful scenic beach a hot spot for surfing and storm-watching enthusiasts. It is a beautiful and pristine beach on which having a lounge time or walking feels rejoiced. You can lose yourselves in the sand of Long Beach and find them once again.

Camping in the Alder Bay RV Park & Marina

Camping in the Alder Bay RV Park & Marina

While exploring the northern parts of Vancouver Island, why not relax a day or two in a fantastic campground? Alder Bay RV Park & Marina offers undeniable RV camping with ocean views that can touch your soul. The great ocean-atmosphere, incredible marine life and gorgeous sunsets add up to the reasons why you should camp in this campground.

Goose Spit Regional Park Kiteboarding

Goose Spit Regional Park Kiteboarding

When you plan to choose a destination to go kiteboarding, you will get lost in the reasons you should select Goose Spit Regional Park. A scenic beach including a fantastic ecosystem will provide you with a handful of activities, kiteboarding in particular. Diverse wildlife is also observable.

Nitinat Triangle Kayaking and Canoeing

Nitinat Triangle Kayaking and Canoeing

Nitinat Triangle provides an excellent opportunity for those fearless paddlers that lets them set their adventure-thirsty souls on fire. Schedule your trip to Nitinat Triangle when you have 4 or 5 days free. The triangle features campsite facilities and magnetic vies of the land.

Solo Travel in Tofino

Solo Travel in Tofino

Tofino, British Columbia, is a breathtaking coastal haven on Vancouver Island’s rugged west coast, often described as a beautiful village that captivates the hearts of solo travelers. Spanning just 10.5 square kilometers, this tiny district on Vancouver Island is a paradise of windswept beaches, ancient rainforests, and a vibrant surf culture, making it one of the best solo travel Tofino destinations in Canada. Whether you’re a woman embarking on a solo travel to Tofino female adventure, a senior seeking solitude, or an adrenaline junkie craving a month-long solo surf trip, Tofino’s unique blend of accessibility, safety, and natural wonder makes it an ideal choice.
Imagine waking up to the sound of crashing waves at Long Beach, hiking through the moss-draped cedars of Pacific Rim National Park, or sipping a latte at a cozy, café as the Pacific Ocean’s mist rolls in. Tofino’s appeal lies in its compact size, easy to navigate solo, paired with its welcoming community of fewer than 2,000 residents, who embody a laid-back, outdoor-loving spirit. With a low crime rate and a reputation for hospitality, Tofino offers a stress-free solo travel Tofino experience.
What sets Tofino apart? It’s a place where you can paddle through Clayoquot Sound’s serene waters, spot orcas on a whale-watching tour, or unwind with a craft beer at Tofino Brewing Company, all on your own terms. From its world-renowned surfing to its Indigenous cultural heritage, Tofino is a solo trip idea Canada that promises adventure and introspection. Whether you’re planning a quick weekend getaway or an extended Tofino trip, this guide will equip you with everything you need to make it unforgettable.

Ucluelet Whale Watching

Ucluelet Whale Watching

Make your Whale watching experience memorable enough to remember it even with closed eyes. in Ucluelet, you will have ample opportunities to encounter these gigantic marine creatures, and you may be lucky to observe other wildlife too. Those whale watching enthusiasts have the chance to attend the annual Pacific Rim Whale Festival happening at the Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, Ucluelet and Tofino on Vancouver Island's west coast.

Hiking on Mount Manuel Quimper

Hiking on Mount Manuel Quimper

It is time to put your heart into hiking and step into a moderate multi-use trail with some great views along the way and on top. Mount Manuel Quimper has a beautiful summit worth the climb, which gives you excellent vistas of Sooke Harbour and a chance to visit one of the last fire lookouts left on the island.

Vancouver Island Activities

Kitty Coleman Beach & Bates Beach Surfing

Kitty Coleman Beach & Bates Beach Surfing

Leave your job and its responsibilities for a few days and try to feed your soul. If you are looking for a way to add excitement to your journey, Kitty Coleman Beach & Bates Beach will provide you with great opportunities to embrace and skim the surface of the water. Wave surfing on Kitty Coleman Beach and the low-tide pools of Bates Beach would make you feel fully charged and ready to get back doing your job.

Ladysmith Kayaking

Ladysmith Kayaking

Exceptional opportunities to explore the water while enjoying the scenic view of a city with a hundred years of history and culture preserved within the realms of Ladysmith. as an ideal kayaking destination, Ladysmith has several offerings to make your stay even more joyful. So, pack your bags and hit the road to this beautiful old city.

Hiking on the Riley Lake to Lookout Loop to Lost Frog

Hiking on the Riley Lake to Lookout Loop to Lost Frog

In an area with several hiking options having the experience of hiking a relatively long trail would be great as it is rich in natural beauties. Besides hikers, Riley Lake to Lookout Loop to Lost Frog is proper for mountain bikers and nature trip lovers. Just find yourself northwest of Campbell River and get the most out of your backpacking trip.

Sidney Kayaking

Sidney Kayaking

Views of Olympic and Cascade Mountain ranges, besides appealing sea excursions, make Sidney a paradise for tourists and suitable for kayaking. Sidney's moderate Mediterranean climate with relatively low rainfall is the reason behind its popularity among paddling enthusiasts. Also, recreational sites around Sidney have made it an ideal place to make beautiful memories while exploring the incredible opportunities provided for you.

Breakwater Island Diving

Breakwater Island Diving

Make immortal memories of diving in the Breakwater Island Diving zone. This famous diving location has a lot to offer. Whether on land or in water, a variety of creatures inhabit the area you cannot get enough and fantastic scenery which can multiply the amazement of your stay in this region.

Bamfield Whale Watching

Bamfield Whale Watching

Adjacent to Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, Bamfield is a favourable destination for whale watching in the Port Alberni area. To make the most out of your journey in Bamfield, you can do salmon fishing around the coast and enjoy the outstanding birdlife living there.

Kyuquot Sound Surfing

Kyuquot Sound Surfing

Rebuild your imagination about surfing while you are having a great time in the Kyuquot Sound area, an area of world-class beaches and reefs. Featuring amazing natural scenery which can cheer you up while you are skimming the surface of the water. The beautiful sandy beach features an eye-catching view that can trigger you to camp and surf on one of the largest campsites on Vancouver Island.

Cowichan Lake Windsurfing

Cowichan Lake Windsurfing

You would have the chance to re-invent your expectation of windsurfing by embracing the opportunities given to you on the second-largest lake of Vancouver Island. Cowichan Lake does not only serve your desires for windsurfing and is a paradise for those in love with water activities. If you are looking for a time to make the most of it in the Cowichan Lake area, plan to come during April.

Island View Beach Kiteboarding

Island View Beach Kiteboarding

Meet your inner kiteboarder while you are on Island View Beach. A beautiful sandy beach, offering undeniable opportunities for adventure. Kiteboarding facilities provided for you will fulfill your expectations. Moreover, abundant birds are observable, and you can enjoy several outdoor activities offered for you on this cute sandy beach.

Hiking on the Mount Benson Loop

Hiking on the Mount Benson Loop

Wear your hiking boots! It is going to be a challenging hike that may take about 4 to 5 hours. The lovely amount of elevation with fantastic views is what you can get hiking on the Mount Benson Loop near Nanaimo. As it is located in a reach environment, take lots of breaks to enjoy the area and get enough energy. If you are not ready for wet terrains, try it on a dry and cool day. You would be satisfied as an experienced hiker.

Fishy Hole Cave, a renowned Vancouver Island karst cave, is primarily composed of ancient limestone deposits formed in shallow marine environments. Over millions of years, chemical weathering, freeze-thaw cycles, and water erosion have sculpted its remarkable speleothem formations such as stalactites and stalagmites. These processes, documented by BC geological studies and modern speleological research, make Fishy Hole Cave a prime example of Canadian karst landscapes.
Profile Picture

Anita Akhoundi

2025 April 6

Your Adventure Starts with Vancouver Island Tours

4 Hour Scenic Tour and Salmon Fishing | VI-FT-014

Private coastal sightseeing and salmon fishing charter departing from Nanaimo, perfect for families and anglers of all levels.
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $660
4 Hours
4 Hour Scenic Tour and Salmon Fishing | VI-FT-014

8hr Nanaimo Private Fishing Tour | VI-FT-013

Full Day Private Fishing Adventure in the Stunning Waters of Nanaimo
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $1,200
8 Hours
8hr Nanaimo Private Fishing Tour | VI-FT-013

6 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter | VI-FT-012

Private 6-Hour Vancouver Island Salmon Fishing Charter in Nanaimo
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $960
6 hours
6 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter | VI-FT-012

4 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter Private Tour | VI-FT-011

Private Guided Salmon Fishing Adventure in Nanaimo
Group
Nanaimo
Nanaimo
from $660
4 Hours
4 Hour Nanaimo Fishing Charter Private Tour | VI-FT-011

Comox Spring Coastal Explorer & Fishing Trip | VI-FT-009

Explore the Salish Sea on a relaxed guided coastal adventure combining angling, wildlife watching, and island exploration.
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $800
5 to 6.5 hours
Comox Spring Coastal Explorer & Fishing Trip | VI-FT-009

5-Hour Half-Day Salmon Fishing Trip | VI-FT-008

Experience premier guided salmon fishing trips in the Comox Valley with Island Pursuit Sport Fishing.
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $800
5 Hours (Half Day)
5-Hour Half-Day Salmon Fishing Trip | VI-FT-008

Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 6 Hour Trip | VI-FT-007

Experience premium guided fishing trips in Comox targeting salmon, cod, and crab year-round.
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $975
6 Hours (Ranges from 5 to 6.5 hours)
Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 6 Hour Trip | VI-FT-007

Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 8 Hour Day Trip | VI-FT-006

Premier Vancouver Island Fishing Charter Targeting Salmon, Bottom Fish & Crab Year-Round
Group
Comox
Salish Sea
from $1,275
8 Hours
Island Pursuit Sport Fishing: 8 Hour Day Trip | VI-FT-006

Barkley Sound Halibut Fishing Trip | VI-FT-005

Experience world-class halibut jigging and salmon trolling aboard the Oracle with award-winning captain Orest Iwaszko.
Group
Alberni Valley
Barkley Sound
from $0
Multi-day overnight packages, 8-hour salmon and halibut trips, and 5-hour trips available.
Barkley Sound Halibut Fishing Trip | VI-FT-005

Private Sockeye Fishing Trip | VI-FT-004

Experience a private sockeye salmon fishing charter in Alberni Inlet, Vancouver Island. Luxury hybrid-electric trawler, expert captain, and all-inclusive fishing adventure for groups of 4 to 11 people during peak June–July season.
Group
Alberni Valley
Alberni Inlet
from $1,480
Full-Day Trip
Private Sockeye Fishing Trip | VI-FT-004

Private 2 Day Fishing Trip | VI-FT-002

Comfortable, private group fishing adventure in Barkley Sound for up to 11 guests
Group
Port Alberni
Barkley Sound
from $185
8 hours (private trip with flexible pacing based on conditions)
Private 2 Day Fishing Trip | VI-FT-002

Sea Lions & Eagles Adventure

Experience an Unforgettable Half-Day Adventure in the Heart of Fanny Bay
Group
Nanaimo
from $2,850
1 day
Sea Lions & Eagles Adventure

4-Day Wildlife Watching on Vancouver Island

Pacific Rim & Clayoquot Sound Adventure
Group
Nanaimo
Tofino
from $1,897
4 days and 3 nights
4-Day Wildlife Watching on Vancouver Island

Fly Fishing Tour on Vancouver Island

Fly-Fishing Paradise on the Gold River
Group
Campbell River
Gold River BC
from $1,400
1 day
Fly Fishing Tour on Vancouver Island

Victoria Kayak Fishing Adventure Tour

Explore Inner Harbour & Catch Inshore Fish
Group
Victoria
Victoria
from $1,000
2 days and one night
Victoria Kayak Fishing Adventure Tour

Port Renfrew Bottom Fishing Tour

Guided Fishing Adventure Tour on Port Renfrew Vancouver Island
Group
Victoria
Port Renfrew
from $1,475
3 days and 2 nights
Port Renfrew Bottom Fishing Tour

What Do You Think about